Subscribe to Comments 2.1
Subscribe to Comments 2.1 is a plugin that allows commenters on your blog to check a box before commenting and get e-mail notification of further comments. It is one of the most popular WordPress plugins out there for the simple reason that it helps foster a community around your blog by encouraging commenters to come back and stay engaged in the dialog.
Features
- Rudimentary security
- Users cannot enter a random e-mail into the subscription manager and modify someone else’s subscriptions
- In order to modify subscriptions, users need to use a special link, given in notification e-mails, and printed in the comments form as long as they have their comment cookie
- Recognition of subscription status
- Unsubscribed users see the “subscribe to comments” checkbox, but subscribed users see a “Manage your subscriptions” link
- The author of the post is recognized by either login or comment cookie and is assumed to be subscribed to the entry (as they will receive notifications through WordPress)
- Themeable subscription manager
- Uses visual style of WordPress interface
- Can be optionally accessed via “Manage” menu in WordPress
- E-mail verification of block requests
- Javascript “invert selection” link to check/uncheck subscriptions for mass deletion
- “Return to the page you were viewing” link that persists at the top of the page, so that users can easily return to the post they were reading once they are done modifying subscriptions
- Ability to let users change notification e-mail address
- In the subscription manager, users can request that their notification address be changed for all their subscriptions
- Special link is sent to the old address for verification
- Once clicked, their e-mail address will be changed instantly for all their comments
- Easy integration into comments form
- No modification of comments form needed for WP 1.5+ (supported themes)
- For users who want custom placement of the checkbox/link to subscription manager, this can be done with one simple function call, placed anywhere in the comment form
- Subscription without leaving a comment
- By popular demand, you can now offer visitors the option of subscribing to comments on an entry without having to leave a comment themselves
- If the reader later decides to join the conversation, their subscription continues without them having to explicitly set it
- Customization
- You can make the Subscription Manager that your users see use your theme’s header, footer and sidebar, using CSS to style it to fit your site
- Internationalization
- I’ve written Subscribe to Comments 2.1 with i18n in mind, making full use of
__()and_e()functions. The domain is “subscribe-to-comments”.
- I’ve written Subscribe to Comments 2.1 with i18n in mind, making full use of
Download
Version 2.1 Update
Version 2.1 of Subscribe to Comments has a feature that people have been begging me to implement for many months: you can view the list of people who are subscribed to posts on your blog, and you can also see a list of the most “subscribed” posts. Also in this version is a new one-file install. You just put subscribe-to-comments.php in your /plugins/ directory, activate, and you’re done. This version will work on WordPress versions from 2.0.6 through 2.3.1 (highest tested).
Versions
- 2.1.2 Fixed a few bugs that’d send bad notifications (thanks Donncha!), cleaned up some code and moved to using proper WP escaping functions
- 2.1.1 WordPress 2.2 compatibility! Also note that support for
attribute_escape()is needed, so if you get errors about that, upgrade to the latest version in your branch - 2.1 big update, fixing a few potential XSS holes, and misc error messages… see above for details
- 2.0.8 XSS security fixes, hopefully fixed “+” symbols in e-mail for good
- 2.0.7 additional “funky e-mail” fixes
- 2.0.6 support for e-mail addresses with “+” symbols, option to disable CSS “clearing”
- 2.0.4 potential security bugs, better WP 2.0 capabilities compat
Feedback/Bugs
Feel free to leave bug reports or feature requests here. Use this entry’s comments to ask support questions or offer general feedback


I´m very happy with this pugings.
Thanks you!!!
good job
thanks
What a great plugin, everyone should donate money to your blog - well worth it!
The Modern Mike
I can’t make this work. It installs OK and I get the checkbox on the comments form, but it doesn’t email the commenter when another comment is added.
Is there something obvious or should it work out-of-the-box?
Any chance you’ll offer the ability to specify which email method to use? I use IIS and haven’t found an easy way to use anything but smtp.
Thanks,
David
I have Bad Credit Debt Consolidation Non Secured Personal Loans and I search where i can go to get a Personal Loans With Bad Credit
very interesting, but I don’t agree with you
Idetrorce
I still can’t get this plugin to email people, It works and shows everything but doesn’t email
Dale
http://dzrbenson.com/blog/
Dale,
I have the same problem. The plugin doesn’t email. But I don’t think anyone addresses problems on this site.
Great plugin, I really love it! But how do I get translation to work? Simply create a subscribe-to-comments-de_DE.po in the plugins directory, translating some stuff and creating a subscribe-to-comments-de_DE.mo file does not work…
For those having trouble getting this plugin to work, I implemented the fix suggested by Diz in comment #3058 above, and now it seems to be working.
@Mark: I suggest that you separate the comments and trackbacks to make it easier to follow the comment thread.
Thanks for trying, Ken. But I’m using version 2.1.2, where that bit of code is written correctly.
Still can’t make it send an email, though.
Same i am using the newest version, but still won’t email
What worked for us was adding the email account “wordpress@domain.com”
Dumb, but it worked.
Steve, where did you add that email address?
Has everyone else had to do this?
Why isn’t it documented somewhere?
If memory serves, adding wordpress@domain.com as an actual email address on the email server made a difference. I’m not a tech person, we struggled for ages and then it worked.
If memory serves, adding wordpress@domain.com as an actual email address on the email server made a difference. I’m not a tech person, we struggled for ages and then it worked.
You mean adding that email address with the email server of the ISP hosting my copy of Wordpress?
yes. with your actual domain name.
I’ve tried it with more themes than I can count so I ruled that out. Same here, but it’s only happening in Explorer, not in Firefo
Hi folks,
I wonder if anyone has a fix for these two problems. I’ve installed the plugin and then manually entered the
code into my single post page right underneath thecode. The subscribe checkbox is showing correctly in IE but in Firefox(PC) it shows all the way at the bottom of the page.Additionally, when in the Options–>Subscribe to Comments settings, I have this option…”Do a CSS “clear” on the subscription checkbox/message (uncheck this if the checkbox/message appears in a strange location in your theme)”. However, when I UNCHECK this box and Update Options, it stays unchecked…but…when I logout and log back in, this box is checked again.
Any thoughts on what I might try? I’m using WP 2.3.1
Hi,
I have not try this version yet but i will soon
tq
Nielson/NetRatings has issued a study showing that the top 10 social networking sites saw traffic grow 47% over the last year, with MySpace seeing the biggest growth (367% increase) and MSN Spaces (286%) seeing the biggest growth. Hosted blogging systems were included in the study.
One thing to note about those numbers is that while Classmates had one of the lowest positive growth rates at 10%, they spend loads on advertising while MySpace, Youtube, and Facebook haven’t spent a penny.
If I recall correctly, a couple years ago Classmates.com was one of the 10 largest spenders on online advertising.
There are plenty of new social networking sites poping up but what get’s me why can’t myspace there instant messenger working. $580 mill and can’t afford to fix instant messenger BAD myspace.
There are so many better ones how about http://cubiclelife.net for example has all the features of myspace plus quizzes, polls, webchat with audio and video oh and hey they have instant messenger. You have a long way to go myspace.
http://seekingalpha.com/wp-content/seekingalpha/images/socialnetapr06.jpg
Is the best way to upgrade from 2.1.1 to 2.1.2 just to deactivate, replace files, and activate?
Updated German translation for v2.1.2:
http://steinbrecher-online.com/web/files/subscribe_to_comments-de.zip
My life’s been completely boring these days. Not much on my mind recently, not that it matters. Today was a complete loss. Maybe tomorrow. Pretty much nothing seems important.
Entering wordpress@domain.tld (where domain.tld is the domain WordPress is running on) as sender mail address worked for me, too. Before entering the mail address like this the plugin did not send a single mail.
Thanks
Thanks you very much!!!
Finally got it to work, I created a wordpress@domain.com email account
Cheers
Dale
http://dzrbenson.com/blog
The “checkbox” and “Manage Subscriptions” are appearing two far down in the form with Firefox users but works just fine with IE users…I’m not sure why this occurs..any ideas????
Just installed Wordpress MU at and looking for compatible plugins until I stumbled on this. Great work!
I solved the problem with Firefox. I opened the file and changed the clear:both to clear:none in different places. It wasn’t playing nice with my theme and Firefox.
Subscribe to Comments 2.1 worked straight out of the box with email and all on Foliovision.com. There’s $10 in the kitty for no hassle install. Thanks a million.
Do you have a recommendation for comment preview? I’d prefer something server-side and not live.
1. add a preview button:
http://blogwaffe.com/ajax-comment-preview/
2. http://wordpress.org/extend/plugins/live-comment-preview/
This plugin uses only client-side Javascript to format a preview, it does not make any Ajax requests to the server. This provides a smooth live preview as you type.
@ Damnprinter,
Thanks so much for posting the answer. I changed the very first instance of style=”clear: both;” to style=”clear: none;” in the subscribetocomments.php file and now the subscribe checkbox is in the right spot in Firefox.
The trac page linked above won’t let me create a new bug ticket. So I’ll leave a note here:
To make translations work (on a wordpress 2.3.1) I had to change line 826 from
load_plugin_textdomain(’subscribe-to-comments’)
to
load_plugin_textdomain(’subscribe-to-comments’, ‘wp-content/plugins/subscribe-to-comments/’);
Thanks for your plugin!
Hello Mark,
There are a few things which you should be aware of.
First, your I have received $0 this month for my coding efforts counter is not working. I put $10 in there and it isn’t showing up. I think yo should fix this as it is discouraging to other developers and misleading to donors.
Second, your weblog comments are absolutely filled with junk comments and spam.
Most of #3115, #3123, #3120, #3128 are links to gay porn.
2lazKD Hello Zhopa! Google.
Hi Benedikt,
unfortunally your translation hack did not work here. I’m also running WordPress 2.3.1 (but maybe interfering by Polyglot plugin for multilanguage blog).
I tried you hack, nothing happened. I also tried
load_plugin_textdomain(’subscribe-to-comments’, ‘wp-content/plugins/’);
because I did not create a subdirectory for the subscribe-to-comments plugin.
Regards,
Martin
Working like a charm on my blog i love it thanks man!
Hi all, we translated the 2.1.1 version of plugin into spanish (Spain). If you want download it, we uploaded it in http://www.navalcarbon.com/subscribe-to-comments-211-en-espanol/
Congratulations for the plugin!!
it is usefull plugin for wordpress user
tjx for plugin